УДК 930.22

DOI 10.28995/2073-0101-2018-3-809-820

Alexandr M. Pashkov

Petrozavodsk State University, Petrozavodsk, Russian Federation

‘… The “Popularity” of Doctors Should Not Be the Sole Reason for Their Arrest as Hostages’: The Red Terror of Autumn 1918 in Documents from the National Archive of the Republic of Karelia

Abstracts

September 2018 will see the 100th anniversary of the beginning of the Bolshevik Red Terror, first announced on September 2, 1918. Although in Russia in the last 20 years there have been published some valuable synthesis works on the history of the Red Terror of 1918, many details, especially of its realization at the local level, remain little-studied. The National Archive of the Republic of Karelia stores in its fond R-460 ‘Petrozavodsk City Soviet’ a file entitled ‘Excerpts from the minutes of the Olonets Gubernia Revolutionary Executive Committee and Military Commissariat meetings; correspondence with the gubernia Emergency Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage on arrests of hostages in response to the “White Terror,” etc.’ Virtually, the file contains documents on the realization of the Red Terror in Petrozavodsk in autumn 1918. The documents implicate that in realization of the Red Terror at least three organizations were involved: Olonets gubcheka (gubernia Emergency Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution), Petrozavodsk City Soviet, and Olonets gubernia revolutionary tribunal. Thus, headcount of the Red Terror victims should include alongside with persons executed by the VChK, those sentenced by other authorities and those who fell victim to extrajudicial execution. Besides documents on realization of the Red Terror in Petrozavodsk, the file stores command papers from the centre. For instance, the article cites telegram from People’s Commissar of Internal Affairs Gregory Petrovsky to all ‘Sovdeps’ (Soviets of deputies) of September 26, 1918. It avowed arresting doctors as hostages because of their ‘popularity’ and clarified that arrests predicated on nothing more than ‘popularity’ were unwarrantable, as gubernia doctors were ‘the most popular element’ and their mass arrests could ‘disorganize only just set going medical and sanitary activities in the gubernias, particularly, control of epidemics.’ Thus, the telegram confirms a very important fact: typically or by chance, in autumn 1918 not just active opponents of the Bolsheviks, their sympathizers or families members, but anyone enjoying authority and respect could fall victim to the Red Terror.

Download the article: pashkov_doi

Keywords

The Red Terror, archive documents, Petrozavodsk City Soviet (Sovdep), People's Commissariat of Public Health, People's Commissariat of Internal Affairs, mass arrests of physicians, hostage system, Gregory Petrovsky.

References

BULDAKOV, V. P. Krasnaya smuta. Priroda I posledstviya revoluthionnogo nasiliya [The Red Upheaval: Nature and consequences of the revolutionary violence. In Russ.]. Moscow, ROSSPEN publ., 1997, 376 p.

BULDAKOV, V. P. Krasnaya smuta. Priroda I posledstviya revoluthionnogo nasiliya [The Red Upheaval: Nature and consequences of the revolutionary violence. In Russ.]. Moscow, ROSSPEN, fond B.N. Yeltsyna publ., 2010, 968 p.

GALIN, V. V. Interventsiya i grazhdanskaya voina [The Intervenrion and the Civil War. In Russ.]. Moscow, Algoritm publ., 2004, 608 p.

GOLDIN, V. I., ZHURAVLEVA, P. S., SOKOLOVA, F. Kh. Russkii Sever v istoricheskom prostranstve rossiiskoi grazhdanskoi voiny [The Russian North in the Historical Space of the Russian Civil War. In Russ.]. Arkhangelsk, Solti publ., 2005, 350 p.

GOLDIN, V. I. Grazhdanskaya voina v Rossii skvoz’ prizmu let: istoriograficheskie protsessy [The Civil War in Russia through the prism of years: Developments in historiography. In Russ.]. Murmansk, Murmanskii gosudarstvennyi gumanitarnyi universitet publ., 2012, 334 p.

DOIKOV, Yu. V. Krasnyi terror. Rossiya. Ukraina. 1917-1924 [The Red Terror. Russia. Ukraine. 1917-1924. In Russ.]. Arkhangelsk, 2008, 680 p. [on-line]. Available at: http://kak.znate.ru/docs/index-12715.html (accessed 25.05.2018).

DUKHOVSKII, S. I. Obzor deyatel'nosti Narodnogo komissariata vnutrennikh del RSFSR i mestnykh sovetov s kontsa oktyabrya 1917 goda do nachala 1919 goda [Review of the activities of the People’s Commissariat of Internal Affaires of the RSFSR and those of local Soviets from October 1917 to early 1919. In Russ.]. Moscow, 1919, 80 p.

ZHIROMSKAYA, V. B. Problema krasnogo i belogo terrora v otechestvennoi istoriografii [The problem of the Red and White terror in 1917-1920 in national historiography. In Russ.]. IN: Trudy Instituta rossiiskoi istorii [SAKHAROV A.N. (ed.). Proceedings of the Institute of Russian history]. Issue 5. Moscow, Nauka publ., 2005, pp. 240-265.

KIPNIS, S. E. Novodevichii memorial. Nekropol’. Novodevichego kladbistcha [Novodevichy memorial. The necropolis of the Novodevichy cemetery. In Russ.].Moscow, Propilei publ., 1995, 431 p.

KONYAEV, N. M. Gibel’ krasnykh Moiseev. Nachalo terrora. 1918 god [Twilight of Red Moses. The beginning of the Terror: 1918. In Russ.]. Moscow, Veche publ., 2016, 496 p.

Krasnyi terror glazami ochevidtsev [VOLKOV, S. V. (ed.). The Red Terror in eye-witness testimonies. In Russ.]. Moscow, Airis-press publ., 2014, 448 p.

Krasnyi terror v Moskve: svidetel’stva ochevidtsev [VOLKOV, S. V. (ed.). The Red Terror in Moscow: Eye-witness testimonies. In Russ.]. Moscow, Airis-press publ., 2010, 496 p.

Krasnyi terror v Petrograde [VOLKOV, S. V. (ed.). The Red Terror in Petrograd. In Russ.]. Moscow, Airis-press publ., 2011, 528 p.

LITVIN, A. L. Krasnyi I belyi terror v Rossii. 1918-1922 [The Red and White Terror in Russia. 1918-1922. In Russ.]. Moscow, Eksmo publ., 2004, 448 p.

MOZOKHIN, O. B. Pravo na repressii. Vnesudebnye polnomochiya organov gosudarstvennoi besopasnosti (1918-1953) [Right to Repressions: Extrajudicial powers of state security agencies (1918-1953). In Russ.]. Moscow, Kuchkovo Pole publ., 2011, 752 p.

PASHKOV, A. M. Krasnyi terror v Petrozavodske osen’yu 1918 goda [The Red Terror in Petrozavodsk in autumn 1918. In Russ.]. IN: Vestnik Universiteta Dmitriya Pozharskogo [Bulletin of the Dmitry Pozharsky University]. 2016, no. 1(3), pp. 63-89.

RAT’KOVSKII, I. S. Krasnyi terror I deyatel’nost’ VChK v 1918 godu [The Red Terror and the VChK activities in 1918. In Russ.]. St. Peterburg, SPbGU publ., 2006, 286 p.

RAT’KOVSKII, I. S. Stolitsa Krasnogo terrora (Petrograd osen’yu 1918 goda) [The capital of the Red Terror (Petrograd in autumn 1918). In Russ.]. IN: Mir ekomomiki i prava, 2013, no. 7-8, pp. 67-79.

RAT’KOVSKII, I. S. Khronika Krasnogo terrora VChK. Karayustchii mech revolutsii [The chronicle of the VChK Red Terror. The retributive sword of the Revolution In Russ.]. Moscow, Eksmo publ., 2017, 320 p.

SOKOLOV, Yu. V. Narodnyi komissar vnutrennikh del G. I. Petrovskii [People’s Commissar of Internal Affaires G.I. Petrovsky. In Russ.]. IN: Pervoe Sovetskoe pravitel'stvo. Oktyabr' 1917 – iyun' 1918 [NENAROKOV, A. P. (ed.). First Soviet Government]. Moscow, Politizdat publ., 1991, pp. 341-356.

MAYER, A. J. The Furies: Violence and Terror in the French and Russian Revolutions. Princeton, 2000, 656 p.

About author

Pashkov Alexandr Mikhailovich, PhD in History, professor, Petrozavodsk State University, National History Department, professor, Petrozavodsk, Russian Federation, +7-911-401-38-38, This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Submitted 30.03.2018, published:

PASHKOV, A. M. “…Odna tol'ko “populyarnost'” vrachei ne mozhet sluzhit' prichinoi aresta v zalozhniki”. “Krasnyi terror” oseni 1918 g. v dokumentakh Natsional'nogo arkhiva Respubliki Kareliya [‘… The “Popularity” of Doctors Should Not Be the Sole Reason for Their Arrest as Hostages’: The Red Terror of Autumn 1918 in Documents from the National Archive of the Republic of Karelia. In Russ.]. IN: Vestnik arhivista / Herald of an Archivist, 2018, no. 3, pp. 809-820. doi 10.28995/2073-0101-2018-3-809-820