The case of the organization of public readings in the city of Bryansk. 1894-1899 years

Scientific article

doi 10.28995/2073-0101-2025-2-621–639

For citation

Gularyan, Artem B. (2025). The case of the organization of public readings in the city of Bryansk. 1894-1899 years, Herald of an Archivist, № 2, pp. 621–639, doi 10.28995/2073-0101-2025-2-621–639

Gularyan, Artem B., N. V. Parakhin Oryol State Agrarian University, Oryol, Russia

The case of the organization of public readings in the city of Bryansk. 1894-1899 years

Abstract

After the abolition of serfdom and the beginning of capitalist modernization in Russia, the issue of increasing the literacy rate of the population became acute. The educated public - censored and non-censored intelligentsia - took an active part in solving this issue and participated in the development of various forms of extracurricular education. One of such educational activities was the organization of “public readings”, during which illiterate audiences were shown “luminous pictures” and literary works were read aloud. Scholars who have studied this sociocultural practice have come to the conclusion that folk readings were the precursor of cinema and modern mass media. This practice became a widespread form of public work because, firstly, it gained a certain popularity among the urban lower classes, secondly, it became one of the forms of organizing civil society in Russia, and thirdly, it was a tool for forming a public discourse in the country approved by the authorities. That is why the organization of public readings was strictly regulated by rules and was under the full control of the local administration. From all of the above, we can conclude that the topic of organizing folk readings in the Russian provinces is a really important scientific problem. Unfortunately, folk readings in the province, at the provincial level, have not been closely examined in Russian and foreign historiography. The proposed article is intended to partially fill this gap. It is devoted to the reconstruction of the conflict between the governor of Orel A. N. Trubnikov and a group of Bryansk intellectuals over the approval of a special public organization engaged in the conduct of public readings. The study of the conflict is based on the analysis of documents stored in the fund of the Oryol governor in the State Archive of the Oryol region (GASO). The research is based on the method of historicism and traditional (non-formalized) methods of text analysis. On the basis of general logical operations of analysis and synthesis, comparison, evaluation and comprehension, textual analysis of archival documents was carried out. This allowed the author to reconstruct step by step the history of the conflict between the governor of Orel and a group of founders of the Committee of People's Readings in Bryansk. The collision described in the article characterizes the personal style of management established in the Russian bureaucratic system, when the decision on this or that case was determined by the personal favor or disfavor of a high-ranking official.

Keywords

Popular readings, education, regulations, public organization, educated public, governor, committee, draft charter, historical sources.

Download the article: gularyan_doi

References

Agafonova, Y. Ya. (2022). Literature for the people and the central audience for people's readings as a state educational project in the second half of the XIX century, New Literary Review, № 175, pp. 78-92.

Agafonova, Ya. Ya. (2019). Classics for the people in the adaptations of the Permanent Commission on the arrangement of folk readings, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, № 2 (156), pp. 77-93.

An-sky, S. A. (Rapoport, N. A.) (1913). People and the book. Experience of Characterization of the People's Reader, Moscow, Tipografiya L. A. Stolyar publ., 176 p.

Belokonsky, I. P. (1930). In the Years of Dispossession, Moscow, All-Union Society of political prisoners and exiles publ., 159 p.

Vdovin, A. V., Zubkov, K. Y. (ed.) (2023). Institutes of Literature in the Russian Empire, Moscow, Publishing House of the Higher School of Economics publ., 496 p.

Kuzmina, N. G. (2014). Publishing activity of the permanent commission on the arrangement of people's readings, “History of the book” I. P. Khrushchev, Bibliosphere, № 3, pp. 49-51.

Marakuev, V. N. (1886). What read and reads Russian people, Moscow, Tipo-lithography of N. I. Kushnerev and Co publ., 177 p.

Nekrasova, E. S. (1902). Folk books for reading in their 25-year struggle with lubochnykh editions, Vyatka, Vyatka Comradeship publ., 340 p.

Pavlov, M. A. (2000). State regulation of reading in Russia 1890-1917, Dis … Cand. of Philological Sciences, St. Petersburg, 206 p.

Panina, S. V. (1957). On the St. Petersburg outskirts, Novy Zhurnal, Kn. 48, pp. 163-195.

Prugavin, A. S. (1895). The demands of the people and the duties of intellectuals in the field of mental development and enlightenment, St. Petersburg, Tipography of I. N. Skorokhodov publ., 547 p.

Reitblat, A. I. (2009). From Bova to Balmont and Other Works on the Historical Sociology of Russian Literature, Moscow, New Literary Review publ., 448 p.

Rubakin, N. A. (1895). Etudy o russkoy chitushchei publica, St. Petersburg, Sklad editions of N. P. Karbasnikov publ., 246 p.

Rushanin, V. Ya. (2011). Folk readings in the Urals in the late XIX - early XX century, Bulletin of the Chelyabinsk State Academy of Culture and Arts, № 3 (27), pp. 90-94.

Khrushchev, I. P. (1901). On the publishing activities of the Permanent Commission of People's Readings and the Society established under it for fifteen years (1881-1896), St. Petersburg, Permanent Commission for the arrangement publ., 24 p.

Agafonova, Y. (2022). The Common Reader in Public Readings With Magic Lantern Slides in Late Imperial Russia, Slavic Literatures, v. 129, pp. 73-93.

Arnove, R. F., Graff, H. J. (2013). National Literacy Campaigns: Historical and Comparative Perspectives, New York, Springer Science & Business Media publ., 322 p.

Brooks, J. (2003). When Russia Learned to Read. IN Literacy and Popular Literature (1861-1917), Evanston, Illinois, Northwestern University Press publ., 488 p.

Cavallo, G., Chartier, R. A. (2003). History of Reading in the West, Cambridge, Polity publ., 496 p.

Escarpit, R. (1971). Sociology of Literature, London, Cass publ., 104 p.

Lindenmeyr, A. (2012) Building Civil Society One Brick at a Time, People Houses and Worker Enlightenment in Late Imperial Russia, Journal of Modern History, v. 84, № 3, pp. 1-39.

Lyons, M. (2001) Readers and society in nineteenth-century France, Workers, women, peasants, N.Y., Palgrave publ., 208 p.

Lyons, M. (2014). The Power of Scribe: Delegated Writing in Modern Europe, European History Quarterly, v. 44 (2), pp. 244-262.

Wells, K. D. (2015). The Magic Lantern in American Churches Before 1860, Magic Lantern Gazette, A Journal of Research. v. 27, № 4, pp. 3-33.

About authors

Gularyan Artem B., PhD Historical Sciences, Associate Professor, N. V. Parakhin Oryol State Agrarian University, Department of History, Philosophy and Russian Language, Associate Professor, 8-900-486-60-13, This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

The article was received in the editorial office on 04.06.2024, recommended for publication on 20.03.2025